Chapter five
Communication with customers Part 2
Body language
‘Words may lie but the body seldom does!’
To communicate effectively with customers we need to understand the language our body speaks so that we can:
- use it effectively to help others understand what we are saying
- recognise it in others, so that we can more accurately interpret what they are telling us.
All information reaching our brains can only enter via the five senses – sight, hearing, touch, taste and smell. Of those senses, the eyes are the most valuable, transmitting approximately 80% of the information that reaches our brains. About 14% goes in through our ears and the other senses handle the remaining 6%.
The communication ‘cake’ above shows that 55% of the meaning in communication is visual. The problem is that we put most of our effort into organising and delivering the words we use. Our ‘body-talk’ is left to fend for itself, and as a result tends to come out ‘unedited’, communicating what we really feel, which may or may not be helpful!
Here are the main elements of body language (including facial expression) that we need to be aware of:
Posture
Posture concerns the overall bearing of the body. It comprises the angle of the head, shoulders, hips and feet, direction and angle of inclination and position of arms and legs.
In general, people who feel comfortable with a situation and with themselves, raise their head and look openly at you. They may lean back slightly indicating that they are relaxed or lean forward slightly to indicate attentiveness.
People who are on the attack or who feel aggressive generally adopt a ‘full-frontal’ stance with head, shoulders, hips and feet all pointing at you. They will probably raise themselves up and lean forward in a dominating manner. Those who are feeling defensive will probably ‘close-up’ physically, making themselves smaller; hands and arms may protect their mouth or abdomen; legs may be crossed tightly.
People feeling superior and arrogant may cross their legs openly (ankle of one leg resting on the knee of the other) and lean back with their hands clasped at the back of their head.
Arms
People use their arms in a variety of ways. Some gesticulate frequently and others hardly at all. Points worth noting are:
- arms can be used to signify self-protection and defensiveness when they are folded tightly across the abdomen; or they can be held down, with hands clasped casually together, to signify relaxation.
- hands can be used to hide behind, covering part of the face; they can be used to demonstrate openness and honesty by showing open palms; they can be used to cut the air aggressively to emphasize points.
- fingers can be used to fidget, as in drumming the table to indicate impatience or boredom; they can be used to jab the air pointing to you; they can be used to wag at someone like a schoolteacher talking to a naughty pupil; they can be wagged threateningly like a stick.
Handshakes
Shaking hands is a relic of the caveman era – whenever cavemen met they would hold their arms in the air with their palms exposed to show that no weapons were being held or concealed. This gesture became modified over the centuries and is now a form of ritual greeting, in most English-speaking countries.
Some types of handshake!
When the hand is cold or clammy; soft and placid, like a dead fish, people relate it to a weak character.
When people grip your hand so firmly, that you think it will truly break! This handshake is the trademark of the aggressive ‘tough guy’ type.
Again used by ‘aggressive’ types, its main purpose is to keep you at a distance, and out of their intimate zone. It is also used by people who originate from country areas who feel the need to protect their personal territory.
This feels a bit like the ‘stiff-arm thrust’ that has missed its mark. It is also designed to keep the receiver at a distance. The initiator may appear to have a keen and enthusiastic attitude towards the receiver, however they often lack confidence.
Very popular with politicians! The intention is to show sincerity, trust or depth of feeling towards the receiver. They are really only suitable for close family members, or when the initiator wishes to convey empathy. If these circumstances are not present – the receiver may become suspicious and be ‘put-off’!
Legs
Like arm gestures, the gestures of our legs can also tell us a lot about people’s feelings.
Crossed legs are often a signal that a negative or defensive attitude may exist. Where arm-crossing was originally used to defend the heart and upper-body region, leg-crossing may be an attempt to shield the genital area. Crossed legs are less negative than crossed arms. However, care should be taken when interpreting this gesture with women. Many women have been taught that it is the ‘ladylike’ way to sit! It is unfortunate that this gesture can make them appear defensive.
The European Leg-Cross Position is where one leg neatly crossed over the other, is a normal position used by European cultures, and may be used to show a nervous, reserved or defensive attitude. However, this gesture needs to be interpreted with others, and not in isolation or out of context. E.g. People often like to sit like this during lectures, or if they are on uncomfortable chairs for long periods. It is also a common gesture to see in cold weather. However, when crossed legs are combined with crossed arms, the person may have withdrawn from the conversation.
The Leg-Lock Position may indicate that an argumentative or competitive attitude exists. It is a sitting position popular with American males – but not British males! This gesture is considered most offensive in many cultures, where showing the sole of the shoe, or foot, is unacceptable in public.
The Ankle-Lock Position involves crossing, or folding, arms or legs may suggest that a negative or defensive attitude exists – and this is also the case with the crossing of ankles in the standing or sitting-up position. Interviewers who observe this gesture may deduce that the candidate is ‘mentally biting her/his lip’ – indicating a holding back of a negative attitude, emotion, nervousness or fear.
Face
Human beings have more control over their facial muscles than any other animal on this planet! As a result, the face is the most expressive part of our bodies.
The areas around the eyes and mouth are the most expressive. Raised eyebrows and an ‘O’ shaped mouth signify surprise, but raised eyebrows and an open smile indicate real pleasure; knotted eyebrows and a downturned mouth signify sadness, while knotted eyebrows and tightly pursed lips signify displeasure. There is hardly a single emotion that does not show in the face in such a way as to be instantly recognisable by someone else.
Eyes
Eye contact is very important to customer relationships. If we avoid eye contact we can give the impression that we are shifty, lacking in confidence or disinterested. If eye contact is too intense, we might appear aggressive and make the client feel uncomfortable. If our eye contact is immediate and moderate (about 50-70% of the time) we give an entirely different impression. Especially if accompanied by a pleasant facial expression.
We are effectively saying, ‘I am pleased to see you, I feel confident in myself. I am looking forward to our transaction!’.
Stop + Think Activity:
Video yourself using your phone, camera or other device, play it back and see what you think? Play it to family members and friends and ask them what message they get from your usual body language etc? If you’re not happy with it, work on changing it, record it again and compare it with your original recording.
Communication Channels
The communication process begins with the sender who has to make a decision about which channel to use. This could be a letter, e-mail, text, telephone, Skype, or by meeting the person or people face-to-face and speaking to them. Choice of channel is important, though circumstances will play a big part. It would take a lot of time and money to meet someone in London (if you’re in New Zealand) as opposed to sending them an email or phoning them!
However, the channel you choose for your message has a big impact on how it’s received!
E.g. If you wanted to end a personal relationship, would you send the person an email, a text, or a fax? Would you speak to the person in front of other people in public? Or would it be better to speak personally to the individual in private?
It is well known that some folks will exchange multiple emails with a colleague in the next office rather than go through and speak to them! The subject may require discussion, and could probably be sorted in 30 seconds, but for whatever reason (laziness; or they don’t like each other!), the email channel gets used and wastes a lot of time!
Writing
Writing can be great if you need to:
- Reach lots of people at once
- Provide a record for reference later
- Check and fine-tune your message before sending it – useful with tricky or complex messages
- Get a response, but you don’t need it immediately.
- Or maybe you deliberately want to keep a ‘distance’ from the other person. For example when a recruiting manager tells a candidate that they haven’t got the job!
However it’s not so good if the situation needs:
- Discussion in order to get full understanding, or to reach a decision.
And remember, from the communication cake we know that only 7% of the meaning of communication comes from words! So in writing, 93% – the voice and body language – is not available. This is why receivers tend to ‘read between the lines’ to try and flesh out the meaning. And sometimes they get it wrong, and imagine all sorts of interpretations that the sender never intended!
So be very careful with your choice of words, especially when the message has emotional or attitude content!
Phone
Phone is better than writing for discussion or emotional stuff – it has words (7%) plus voice (38%) – 45% of the cake. And it’s instantly two-way.
Face-to-face
There is no doubt that face-to-face communication is the most effective. 100% of the cake is in use, and sender and receiver can go round the cycle as many times as needed. But because the visual (55%) components of body language, including facial expression, are used both parties have the best chance to make themselves understood, particularly with emotional content.
Is it any wonder that companies all round the world spend squintillions of dollars on having sales people visit customers for face-to-face meetings! It’s because this is the most persuasive communication process, and figures prove that meetings get better sales results than phone calls, and phone calls better results than emails and websites. (The meetings are costly though, and results are of course never guaranteed. So wise companies use a mix of sales communication methods, and use meetings only where the chances of a sale are greatest).
Stop + Think Activity:
Identify three recent occasions when you were the ‘sender’ of a communication. (Choose examples where different channels were used). Which channel did you use for each one? Why did you use that one? Was it the best channel to use under the circumstance? Make some notes on these.
Barriers To Communication
Despite all your best efforts at communicating effectively there may still be problems with getting your message across! These problems are described above as ‘interference’ in the Communications Model, and are collectively known as ‘Barriers to Communication’
Barriers to communication exist at both the sending and receiving stages of a communication. Let’s look at some of the most frequent barriers that exist in customer service situations
Sending
Lack of Clarity
Communicating ambiguously (double meanings), or using unclear meanings will result in confusion all round! If the sender chooses the wrong words, or uses words which you don’t understand, you’re going to struggle to keep listening
Articulation
When speaking, lack of clarity is often associated with poor articulation. We need to choose words that make sense to the receiver, and then pronounce them properly and clearly. Mispronunciation can cause ambiguity and mixed messages.
Mumbling…….bumbling……whispering…speaking to the floor….!! “It’s not what you say but the way that you say it…” It doesn’t matter how interesting your message is, if you don’t project a clear voice, in the direction of the ‘audience’, how will they even hear what is said, let alone understand it?!
Non-Verbal Communication
As we saw in 5.4 and 5.5 above, our voice tone and body language convey a lot. For clear communication this needs to ‘match’ what our words are saying. When it does it reinforces our message. When it doesn’t it can be very confusing.
For example if your manager said in a quiet, dull voice, with a flat facial expression, “After lunch I’ve got something really exciting for you”, what would you believe? We’d probably be suspicious and confused!
Why does this happen? Well sometimes we let our underlying emotions prevail, even when we’re communicating on something different. So a contact centre consultant may just have finished a call with an angry and abusive caller who insulted them. On the next call their voice is shaky and weak, projecting a lack of confidence. The new caller then quickly becomes uncertain whether the consultant can help them, irrespective of the words the consultant uses!
Receiving
Not Listening Actively
Inattention (not listening!) accounts for much of the problem! There is a huge difference between listening and hearing – hearing is a physiological process (“I have ears, I can hear”), whereas active listening requires real effort. Competition for attention from everything else going on around us can make it difficult to concentrate solely on listening to what’s being said, and most of us are pretty good at pretending to listen whilst thinking about/doing/looking at something else! (We’ve included more on listening skills in 5.7 below)
Personal issues
If we have a headache, or are feeling tired or unwell, we may find it difficult to listen effectively to others. From time to time we even encounter someone that we really don’t like, and that too can create a personal barrier in our ability to listen effectively.
Lack of Interest
If you have no interest in what is being said, boredom sets in pretty quickly!
Premature Evaluation
… or jumping to conclusions! You may think you know what’s coming next…. and then not bother to listen to the rest of the message.
Culture
Often our non-verbals (what we don’t say) can cause barriers between people from different cultures. Some gestures have different meanings. For example, in some cultures it is polite to belch loudly after a meal to show appreciation, whereas in other cultures, this would be considered very rude. Pointing and spitting are acceptable in some cultures, and not in others. In the PacificIslands it is considered very rude to sit on a desk or table, whereas in other parts of the world it wouldn’t be an issue.
Lack of eye contact is another area that can create barriers in communication. Different cultures have different customs regarding eye contact. Most western cultures regard eye contact positively during conversation and will think a person is rather suspicious or rude if they show reluctance in maintaining eye contact. However in other cultures it can be considered extremely rude and arrogant if you continue eye contact while conversing.
Mistrust and prejudice often affect the communications between cultures. When people of different colour, culture or language interact with one another, there may be an undercurrent of antagonism or suspicion.
When people from different cultures interact – they may each follow different rules of communication – rules that are often unknown to others in the communication. This can result in unintentional insult, inaccurate judgments, and a range of other miscommunications. In the same way, communication techniques that work well to members of one culture may prove disturbing or offensive to members of another.
Emotions
Emotions often act as communication barriers. When we feel intensely, whether it be love, hate, fear, anger… we can’t communicate well! Emotions block out the rational and logical side of our brain stopping us from evaluating and interpreting messages clearly.
Stereotyping
How often have you heard remarks like “Young people nowadays, they’re so selfish/loud/rude….etc..”…? This is standard stereotypical behaviour – where a group of people (often an entire nation!) are judged by the behaviours of a few, and you may well end up treated in a particular way as a result of your age, nationality, appearance or other factors. We tend to approve or disapprove of other people based on our own views and experiences – and this can have a major impact on our interpersonal communication.
Physical Differences
A range of physical barriers exist that can be major causes of misunderstandings or communication breakdowns. Examples include:
- Noise from machinery or people
- Poor eyesight or hearing
- Tiredness
- Poor ventilation
- Stress
- Literacy problems (reading or writing)
Age Differences
An age difference is a major cause of communication difficulties within families. Interests and activities of different age groups don’t always mix! The social conventions of a particular generation may be different to another generation – and anyone who does not follow the ‘rules’ or conventions are considered ‘in the wrong’. Parents have difficulty communicating with their children because a child cannot share the parental experience – while the parent may have forgotten what it’s like to be a child!
Organisational Differences
Within organisations there may be levels of ‘hierarchy’ where people work alongside each other at different levels of authority, for example, Managing Director, Manager, Supervisor, Clerk, Office Junior. Often – people at different levels may experience difficulties in having good effective communication – as their status and role in the organisation is so different.
Organisations may also create communication barriers themselves. The way that information is circulated, or how processes are managed can cause this. Excessive paperwork, secrecy, unnecessary rules and regulations often create barriers and misunderstandings.
It’s clear from the above list that communication barriers can be set up all too easily – and that gaining rapport and achieving smooth relationships can be quite tricky!
Stop + Think Activity
Think of two recent communications you were part of that didn’t go very well. One with an external customer, and one with an internal one. What was the situation? What barriers to communication were present? What was the outcome? Make some notes on this.
Listening Skills
“We were born with two ears and one mouth – we should use them in that proportion!”
As small children we learn speech from the adults around us and begin to develop this skill, increasing our vocabulary as we progress through life. Listening, although the most important skill in effective communication, is not taught and we tend to think of it as a natural function… Provided we have no physical hearing disability, we assume that because we can hear, we already know how to listen, so why do we need to learn to listen effectively?
If you are at all typical, studies have shown that listening takes up more of your waking hours than any other activity! A study of people of various backgrounds showed that 70% of their waking moments were spent in communication, and of that time:
Writing = 9% Reading = 16%
Talking = 30% Listening = 45%
Unfortunately – few people are really good listeners. Researchers claim that 75% of oral communication is ignored, misunderstood or quickly forgotten!
Listening is NOT the same thing as hearing! Hearing is a physiological process – a passive process that occurs without any attention or effort. Listening is quite different – it involves creating meaning for ourselves out of what we hear, and unlike hearing is an ACTIVE process. Listening doesn’t just happen – you must make it happen. Listening takes energy and commitment.
Being able to listen efficiently and effectively will increase your ability to communicate with others.
Remember that the speaker and listener are partners in communication, both are equally important if full understanding is to take place, and both have 50% responsibility for the success of the outcome!
Let’s take a look next at what it is that stops us listening actively, and how we can improve.
Barriers To Active Listening
Thinking time
Although nearly half our time is spent listening, most of us do not listen well, largely because we can think far faster than we can speak. In fact, our brains can process approximately 500 – 800 words in the same time it takes us to speak 200 – 250 words.
This gives us a lot of spare thinking time while we are listening to a person speak. Rather than use this spare time to gather our own thoughts together in order to respond to what the speaker is saying, we let our minds wander. This is just one of the many ways in which we can be distracted and which act as a barrier to effective listening.
Preoccupation with self
In the famous words of Bette Middler,
‘That’s enough about me, let’s talk about you. What do you think about me!’’
This is a classic barrier to active listening because we appear to be listening to somebody speaking but actually we’re thinking about our self, or about a similar situation we found ourselves in.
You may even begin to rehearse your responses, while the other person is still speaking, or you may fall into the habit of ‘capping’! Whatever has happened to them has happened to you – only far worse in your case. So, in an effort to make them feel better about their experience, you respond with something like; ‘Oh, if you think that’s bad, wait until I tell you what happened to me.’! During this time of self-focus, you have inevitably missed what the speaker is saying.
Prejudices
Our personal prejudices can cause us either to switch off mentally, or to be over sensitive to the remarks made by the speaker. Such reactions can be triggered off by the speaker’s clothes, accessories, hair, accent, looks, style of delivery, words used – even the sex or race of the speaker can affect our prejudices.
When our prejudices are active ‘we hear what we want to hear’, and put our own interpretation on what is said. We then spend our thinking time composing rebuttals, questions or even clever responses to trip up or antagonize the speaker.
Environmental/Physical
All of the following factors can make us ‘switch off’ from listening to what is being said, to allow our minds to temporarily concentrate on our surroundings:
- Room too hot; too cold
- Chair too hard; too soft
- Noise (e.g. telephone)
- Lighting too bright; too dim
- Draughts
- Poor ventilation; stuffy atmosphere
- Smells; perfume
- Interruptions
- Distractions – external, such as a fly buzzing round; or internal, such as a random out-of-the-blue thought!
“Are you listening – or are you just waiting for your chance to speak?”
Feedback
In part 1 we discuss how important feedback is. So when we’re the receiver we should volunteer good quality feedback so the sender knows how we’ve interpreted their message. That means when it’s our turn to speak, we don’t just make our next point, but we refer to what they’ve just said first.
When seeking to give customers excellence, this also has the important benefit of acknowledging what they’ve said, and showing that we’re paying attention and taking them seriously. It in effect pays them a compliment, and it’s great for building rapport. (Look back at the things you identified in Section 2 of this book that make you feel bad when you’re the customer. I bet you’ve come across this – not having your point acknowledged!)
However, you can’t properly refer to what they’ve just said unless you were genuinely listening! So giving feedback has one other extremely important benefit! To be able to do it at all, you have to listen actively!
(School teachers know this! If they think that a student isn’t listening they ask them: “What have I just been talking about?” If the student really was day-dreaming then of course they can’t give an answer!)
So here’s another golden rule:
“To be a good listener, always be ready to give feedback”
Questioning
To satisfy customers we need to provide what the customer wants, and for excellence we need to exceed their expectations. But we need to know first what those wants and expectations are! A lot of our communication therefore involves finding out about their wants and expectations, and this means asking questions.
We also, as we have seen above, need to get feedback from them. We need to know if we’ve been understood the way we intended; and whether the things we offer, or do for them, meet their requirements. And we need to know if they agree or disagree with the ideas and propositions we put to them.
So questions are an essential part of our communication process. However our questions are not always effective! Sometimes we don’t phrase our questions very well, and as a result we don’t get very useful answers!
Unfortunately we are ‘on auto-pilot’ 95% of the time, and our questions often just role off the tongue without enough thought!
The most common mistake is to use a ‘closed’ question when an ‘open’ one would be better. This is because we naturally use closed questions 80% of the time, and they tend to be easier to formulate.
Closed Questions
These are questions that can be answered ‘yes’ or ‘no’. They use questioning words like: ‘can’, ‘will’, ‘should’, ‘do’, ‘are’, etc. So they’re great if you just want a ‘yes or no’ answer.
“Do you want to book that now?” …. “Yes”.
Open Questions
These cannot be answered ‘yes’ or ‘no’. So they tend to get more information. The information may be a single word, as in:
What’s your name?” ……. “Andrew”
Or it may be much more, (provided the receiver has something to say!), as in:
What did you think of the Rugby World Cup result?” … “Wow! I was so relieved we won. It was great spectacle too; and brilliant for New Zealand”.
Open questions use the following seven questioning words:
Who, what, where, when, how, why, and which.
What’s the ‘Right’ Question?
The common mistake is to ask a closed question when an open one would be better, as in:
“Didn’t you think the RWC result was fantastic?” … “Yes I did”.
Not only does this get less information form the person, but it’s really about your idea, not theirs! It’s actually just asking if they agree with you – which is fine if that’s what you want to do. The problem comes if we ask our question this way (on auto-pilot) when we really do want to know what they think!
The key therefore, as with all communication is to be clear in our mind what we are trying to achieve – in this case what we want to find out. Then we need to choose the best form of question for that – the most appropriate structure and choice of words.
Action Plan Activity
Based on the ideas covered in chapter 5, and the notes you made from the activities, make plans on how you could improve your communication effectiveness.